Enjoy Authentic Italian Cuisine A Taste of Sicily in the Windy City

View Our Menu

A Tradition of Excellence

Nothing More Authentic than Pizza from Scratch

If there are two things that set Italian cooking apart from any other cuisine from the rest of the world, it must be the mania for fresh ingredients and simplicity of preparation. Whether it’s pizza, pasta, or any other Sicilian specialty that’s served at Alfano’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant, you can bet that it’s been cooked the old-fashioned way. We’ve come all the way to Carthage, IL to let you have a taste of true-blue Italian cuisine.

We are a family-owned-and-operated Italian restaurant that began operations in the early 1970s. We continue the tradition of excellence with menu items, catering options, and an extensive beer and wine selection. Come and dine with us today!